As a specialist shutter company, you might say that we are biased when it comes to advocating plantation shutters over other window treatments.
Ok, hands up, that’s true, but let’s back that up with a comparative analysis with particular emphasis on bay windows.
Our shutters are always custom-made to fit your bay windows, whether you have a box bay window, angled bay window, Georgian-style window, PVC window, or uniquely shaped window.
You can trust that high-quality hardwood shutters, fitted to perfection, will enhance the distinctive features of your bay windows and are more than likely the better option.
Unlike bay window blinds that hang down and block the view, shutters embrace and highlight your windows’ unique shape and characteristics.
With their unique architecture and ability to bring in ample natural light, bay windows often become a focal point in any room.
When it comes to dressing these windows, the choice between bay window shutters vs blinds is significant, as each option offers distinct aesthetic and functional benefits.
Here, we will explore the aspects of shutters and blinds to help homeowners make an informed decision for their bay windows.
A box bay window with cafe style plantation shutters fitted
Aesthetic Appeal
Plantation Shutters
Shutters offer a classic and timeless look often associated with elegance and sophistication. We only use high-quality hardwood timber that can be painted or stained to match the interior design.
Shutters fit snugly within the window frame, enhancing the architectural beauty of bay windows. Their clean lines and structured appearance can complement both traditional and modern interiors.
Whether you choose cafe style shutters, full-height shutters, or tier-on-tier shutters, our shutters offer a range of styles that add to your home’s kerb appeal and value.
Blinds
Blinds are available in various materials such as wood, faux wood, aluminium, and fabric, offering a versatile aesthetic. They come in multiple colours and textures, allowing customisation to match existing, like shutters. They also have a range available, such as:
- Venetian Blinds
- Roller Blinds
- Roman Blinds
- Blackout Blinds
- Vertical Blinds
- Pleated Blinds
- Fabric Blinds
Light Control and Privacy
Shutters
Shutters offer excellent light control. Their louvred design enables precise adjustment of the amount of light entering a room. You can manage the light by tilting the louvres and maintaining privacy while allowing ventilation. This is one of many reasons shutters are popular for living room bay windows.
Additionally, shutters can be fitted with split tilt rods, allowing independent adjustment of the top and bottom halves. This is ideal for living spaces where light needs may vary throughout the day, providing even more flexibility in controlling light levels and privacy.
Blinds
Blinds offer decent light control but are not as precise as shutters. Venetian blinds can be tilted, raised, or lowered, while Vertical Blinds can be tilted and drawn to the side. However, they don’t provide the same insulation and light-blocking level as shutters.
Blackout blinds can help block out light completely, making them a good choice for bedrooms or areas needing maximum privacy.
For older homes (especially those listed), plantation shutters are a perfect way to provide additional insulation.
Insulation and Energy Efficiency
Shutters
Shutters excel in providing insulation and energy efficiency. Their solid construction and close fit to the window frame help reduce heat loss during winter and keep rooms cool in summer.
Shutters create an additional barrier against drafts and can contribute to lower energy bills by maintaining a more stable indoor temperature.
Perfect-fit Shutters also have strong insulation properties that contribute to energy saving, making them ideal for improving their home’s energy efficiency.
They really are the ultimate window dressing for your home!
Blinds
Blinds provide some level of insulation but are much less effective than shutters. Honeycomb blinds, also known as Cellular Blinds, are an exception, as their design traps air within the cells, offering better insulation properties.
The insulating capability largely depends on the material and quality of standard horizontal or vertical blinds.
Our Plantation Shutters are extremely durable and designed to last for years – Even when our dogs use them 😄
Durability and Maintenance
Shutters
Shutters are highly durable and can last for many years with minimal maintenance. They resist warping, cracking, and fading and are easy to clean with just a quick dusting or wipe down.
This makes shutters an incredibly low-maintenance option for homeowners looking for longevity and easy upkeep. Whether you have wooden shutters or faux wood shutters, their durability makes them a long-term investment that adds value to your home.
Blinds
The durability of blinds varies widely based on the material. Aluminium and faux wood blinds tend to be more durable and resistant to moisture, making them suitable for rooms like bathrooms where higher humidity levels are a concern.
Fabric blinds are more prone to wear and tear and require more frequent replacement. Conservatory and Skylight blinds also face similar durability issues depending on their exposure to sunlight.
Completely bespoke, tier-on-tier solid panel shutters fitted to a sash bay window.
Cost Considerations
Shutters
Shutters are more expensive than blinds due to their material, construction, and shutter installation requirements.
Custom-made shutters, designed to fit the specific dimensions and style of bay windows, can add to the cost.
However, shutters’ durability, energy efficiency, and home improvement benefits can offset the initial investment over time.
Blinds
Blinds are typically a more budget-friendly option, with a wide range of prices depending on the material and design. While high-end blinds can be costly, there are many affordable options available.
Installation is usually more straightforward and less expensive than shutters, making blinds a good choice for homeowners on a tighter budget or those looking for a temporary solution.
Related: Why are plantation shutters expensive? – Everything you need to know.
Installation Complexity
Shutters
Installing shutters on bay windows presents a unique challenge due to the intricate measurements and precise fitting required.
Our service is supply and installation only, and we ensure a flawless fit and optimal performance. The shutter installation involves securely placing the frame within the window recess and affixing the shutter blinds panels.
Blinds
Blinds are easier to install and are often suitable for DIY projects. First, brackets are mounted to the window frame or wall, and then the blinds are attached to these brackets.
The simplicity of installing Venetian Blinds, Roller Blinds, or even Honeycomb Blinds makes them a practical DIY option.
Final thoughts
Various factors must be considered when deciding between shutters and blinds for bay windows. Aesthetics, budget, functional requirements, and long-term plans for the home all influence this decision.
Shutters are known for their timeless and elegant look, superior light control and insulation properties. This makes them a worthwhile investment for those prioritising durability and energising.
On the other hand, blinds offer versatility in design, easy installation, and affordability, making them the right choice for homeowners who value customisation and flexibility.
The customisation decision should be based on the specific needs and style of the home. It’s essential to ensure that the chosen window coverings enhance the beauty of the bay windows and their functionality.
One of the main differences is the cost of shutters compared to blinds. As you would expect, the installation service, overall product quality, and benefits of shutters make them more of a costly investment than blinds.
If you have further inquiries about choosing between shutters and blinds or to schedule a consultation for your bay windows, feel free to email [email protected] or call us at 01823 413 330.
We’re here to help you make the perfect choice for your home!
